Forums

Remove Ad
Closed Thread  Post New Thread
 
Thread Tools
Old 15th September 2008   #1 (permalink)
Julia/Anna/Annastein
 
 
Level: 92
Level up: 27%
Activity: 41%
Posts: 27,751
Status: Offline
Default Quebec having the right to become it's own country

For a few years now (I believe) Quebec has wanted to seperate away from Canada and become it's own country. It hasn't happened yet and some people are proclaiming Quebec doesn't have the right to.

First off I'll explain why they do have some rights too.

In 1534
Jacques Cartier (french explorer) came and founded "the new world" now Canada and the USA. The French were there first. They OWNED the land. Ownership of the land seemed to shift back and fourth between the British and the French. In the end France got part of the new world and the rest was British territory. Quebec is now considered "New France" just as the rest of Canada is nicknamed "New England".

If the French were there first and they OWN the land and it's France's territory then why is the rest of Canada against it being it's own country (leader wise not individual people)? It's NEW FRANCE. They were there FIRST. So why can't they become their own country?

Some people see the issue with Quebec becoming it's own country would be there would be trouble with the connection between PEI/ Labrador and the rest of Canada. But isn't Alaska and the U.S.A seperated too? Why can't Quebec become it's own country?
__________________
Quote:
callmesteven wrote: View Post

i love you for you silly :P
^ Yup, that's MY older brother. ;D
Old 15th September 2008   #2 (permalink)
Forum Senior
 
 
Level: 10
Level up: 22%
Activity: 0%
Posts: 439
Status: Offline
Default Re: Quebec having the right to become it's own country

Alaska is a state in America. Hawaii was wanting to do the same, separate from America and become its own country, but it never happened. I think that Quebec never will become its own country because for one it is to small, and when it gets in a war with another country it wont have enough military force to defend its self and eventually get overpowered.
Old 15th September 2008   #3 (permalink)
Born on a Monday.
 
 
Level: 63
Level up: 57%
Activity: 0%
Posts: 26,889
Status: Offline
Default Re: Quebec having the right to become it's own country

Quote:
chargers-2012 wrote: View Post

Alaska is a state in America. Hawaii was wanting to do the same, separate from America and become its own country, but it never happened. I think that Quebec never will become its own country because for one it is to small, and when it gets in a war with another country it wont have enough military force to defend its self and eventually get overpowered.
Luxembourg anyone?
__________________

SOLOMON GRUNDY WANT PANTS TOO!
Old 15th September 2008   #4 (permalink)
Countess of Confusion
 
 
Level: 46
Level up: 31%
Activity: 0%
Posts: 15,733
Status: Offline
Default Re: Quebec having the right to become it's own country

I'm fine with Quebec leaving Canada just as long as they truely become independent. The worry in the West is that, were Quebec to separate, they'd still ask for Canadian assistance and Canada, being the pussy it is, would assent. We don't want to financially support another 'country'.

But apart from that, if Quebec wants to separate, let them. Why should we care? I like Quebec and the Quebecois, don't get me wrong. That's why I think we ought to leave the decision up to the people. But the referendum was shot down and Quebec is still a province. They made their decision and as far as I'm concerned, that's the end of the discussion.

Sorry if I sound like a redneck Albertan oil-driller.
The Following 2 Meezers Support whateverfloats's Post:
Old 15th September 2008   #5 (permalink)
Countess of Confusion
 
 
Level: 46
Level up: 31%
Activity: 0%
Posts: 15,733
Status: Offline
Default Re: Quebec having the right to become it's own country

Quote:
chargers-2012 wrote: View Post

Alaska is a state in America. Hawaii was wanting to do the same, separate from America and become its own country, but it never happened. I think that Quebec never will become its own country because for one it is to small, and when it gets in a war with another country it wont have enough military force to defend its self and eventually get overpowered.
Who's Quebec going to go to war with? Canada can't defend itself either but no one here seems to mind.

Honestly, I think Cascadia is a pretty good idea. Won't happen any time soon but a girl can dream.
Old 15th September 2008   #6 (permalink)
Julia/Anna/Annastein
 
 
Level: 92
Level up: 27%
Activity: 41%
Posts: 27,751
Status: Offline
Default Re: Quebec having the right to become it's own country

Quote:
chargers-2012 wrote: View Post

Alaska is a state in America. Hawaii was wanting to do the same, separate from America and become its own country, but it never happened. I think that Quebec never will become its own country because for one it is to small, and when it gets in a war with another country it wont have enough military force to defend its self and eventually get overpowered.
There are countries which are smaller than Quebec. Point is?
__________________
Quote:
callmesteven wrote: View Post

i love you for you silly :P
^ Yup, that's MY older brother. ;D
Old 15th September 2008   #7 (permalink)
Forum Master
 
 
Level: 16
Level up: 1%
Activity: 0%
Posts: 758
Status: Offline
Default Re: Quebec having the right to become it's own country

Quote:
chargers-2012 wrote: View Post

Alaska is a state in America. Hawaii was wanting to do the same, separate from America and become its own country, but it never happened. I think that Quebec never will become its own country because for one it is to small, and when it gets in a war with another country it wont have enough military force to defend its self and eventually get overpowered.


Quebec certainly isn't geographically small, nor is it particularly small population-wise (nearing 8 million). Either way, who would get in a war with Quebec? Pretty much no one. When was the last time we've seen Canada in a war? I think Quebec would take the same peaceful route.
Old 15th September 2008   #8 (permalink)
Forum Junior
 
 
Level: 5
Level up: 98%
Activity: 0%
Posts: 316
Status: Offline
Default Re: Quebec having the right to become it's own country

Lol. Why?? Are they treated badly by canada....hahaha. Ok.. No seriously whats bad about being apart of canada.
__________________
Elizabeth
Old 15th September 2008   #9 (permalink)
Countess of Confusion
 
 
Level: 46
Level up: 31%
Activity: 0%
Posts: 15,733
Status: Offline
Default Re: Quebec having the right to become it's own country

Quote:
b0udicca wrote: View Post



Quebec certainly isn't geographically small, nor is it particularly small population-wise (nearing 8 million). Either way, who would get in a war with Quebec? Pretty much no one. When was the last time we've seen Canada in a war? I think Quebec would take the same peaceful route.
Canada is in a war right now. It may not seem like it but we are.
Old 15th September 2008   #10 (permalink)
Forum Junior
 
 
Level: 5
Level up: 98%
Activity: 0%
Posts: 316
Status: Offline
Default Re: Quebec having the right to become it's own country

What war against itself?
__________________
Elizabeth

Closed Thread  Post New Thread

Thread Tools

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:34 AM.
To change your timezone, use 'Edit Options' under the 'Settings' menu.




Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.2.0