[crackpott]

rockband all the waaaaaaaaaay !!

[gothicsk8chic]

Rockband is much better with the song choices and graphics, but i think that guitar hero is better in the sense that its much more easier for the part that you only have to worry about one instrument where as in a band its much harder because with the different players they can make the whole band fail which i know gets very anoying

[jedirobotkira]

Rock Band

because they have Avenged Sevenfold

[koflish]

I think both are pathetic excuses for video games.

[rievalentine]

rexdecimal wrote: My feelings toward those games: "When I meet kids I always say to them, Playing guitar is not a f***ing video game... You'll never master it." (Noel Gallagher of Oasis) I know so many idiots who spend hours trying to "master" the controllers, and some of them think it's even giving them the skills to play the corresponding instruments. How can you take pride in that?! Go learn real music, you crazy kids! (I guess the same goes for any video game, but these just rub me the wroooong way) Hate both of them. /downer downer downer

I hate it when they do that too.
But I agree with albertvomit. They do help with hand coordination and hearing.
I play both guitar and saxophone in band and I started out with DDR first. DDR really helped me with sheet music because I can now read it fast enough to play along with it.
But it doesn't work for everyone.
But yeah.
I digress.
Guitar Hero and Rock Band are completely different from real guitar or any other instrument.
But I play them for the fun of it.
I say Guitar Hero because I see more of a challenge out of it.

[m_a_g_g_o_t]

I like guitar hero better because its much easyer for me to handle the guitar.
not sure how, but i believe that the guitar is harder for me to use when it comes to rockband

[rievalentine]

With Rock Band, the guitar that comes with it- the frets are closer than guitar hero's, making it harder to fret.
It's a bit frustrating.

[eleza101]

Guitar hero, i mean come on

[kira717801]

GUITAR HERO!!!!

[gamerkitten]

Neither. Real Insturments FTW.

I miss the older rythym games that didn't have to buy a 50-100$ controller for. Amplitude, Frequency, Bust a Groove 1 & 2, Parappa the Rappa, Um Jammer Lammy, Elite Beat Agents. Sequels people please!